Skip to content

Court Judgment

Court Judgment

Court judgments relating to the Personal Data (Privacy) Ordinance (“PDPO”) and involving issues of public interest, which are arranged in reverse chronological order, are listed below:

  1. Data protection principles
  2. Doxxing
  3. Direct Marketing
  4. Exemptions under Part 8 of the PDPO
  5. Other provisions under the PDPO
  6. Other significant court cases

A. Data protection principles ("DPP")

No. Date of Judgment / Decision Court Case Name Case Number / Citation (if any) Relevant AAB Decisions DPP(s) involved
1 8 May 2015 Court of First Instance Chan Yim Wah Wallace v New World First Ferry Services Limited HCPI 820/2013
[2015] 3 HKC 382
(Decision)
-- DPP 3
2 18 February 2015 Court of First Instance Ng Shek Wai v The Medical Council of Hong Kong HCAL 167/2013
[2015] 2 HKLRD 121
[2015] 3 HKC 455
(Judgment)
-- DPP 3
3 21 February 2014 Court of Appeal Re Chan Hui May Kiu CACV 4/2013
(Judgment)
AAB 7/2011
(Chinese version only)
DPP 1
4 28 August 2008 Court of First Instance Cathay Pacific Airways Ltd v Administrative Appeals Board and Another HCAL 50/2008
[2008] 5 HKLRD 539
[2008] 5 HKC 229
(Judgment)
AAB 3/2007 DPP 1
5 28 March 2000 Court of Appeal Eastweek Publisher Limited & Another v Privacy Commissioner for Personal Data CACV 331/1999
[2000] 2 HKLRD 83
[2000] 1 HKC 692
(Judgment)
-- DPP 1

B. Doxxing

(I) Injunction Orders

No. Date of Order Court Case Name Case Number / Citation (if any) Injunction Order Subject matter
1 30 October 2020 & 13 November 2020 (as continued) Court of First Instance Secretary for Justice v Persons unlawfully and wilfully conducting themselves in any of the acts prohibited under paragraph 1(a), (b) or (c) of the Indorsement of Claim HCA 1847/2020
[2020] 5 HKLRD 638
[2020] HKCFI 2785
(Decision dated 13 November 2020)
Interim Injunction Order

Interim Injunction Order
(as continued)
Injunction against doxxing of judicial officers and/or their family members
2 31 October 2019 & 15 November 2019 (as continued) Court of First Instance Secretary for Justice v Persons unlawfully and wilfully conducting themselves in any of the acts prohibited under paragraph 1(a) and (b) of the Indorsement of Claim and the Internet Society of Hong Kong Limited HCA 2007/2019
[2019] 5 HKLRD 465
[2019] HKCFI 2777
[2019] HKCFI 2809
(Judgment dated 31 October 2019)
(Judgment dated 15 November 2019)
Interim Injunction Order

Amended Interim Injunction Order
(as continued)
Injunction against online publication of violence-inciting materials
3 25 October 2019 & 8 November 2019 (as continued) Court of First Instance Secretary for Justice & Commissioner of Police (suing on his own behalf and on behalf of all other police officers and auxiliary officers as defined in the Police Force Ordinance, Cap 232) v Persons unlawfully and wilfully conducting themselves in any of the acts prohibited under paragraph 1(a), (b) or (c) of the Indorsement of Claim HCA 1957/2019
[2019] 5 HKLRD 500
[2019] HKCFI 2773
(Ruling dated 8 November 2019)
Re-Amended Interim Injunction Order

Amended Interim Injunction Order (as continued)
Injunction against doxxing of police officers and/or their family members

(II) Doxxing-related criminal convictions under the PDPO

No. Date of Conviction & Sentence Sentence Court Case Name Case Number / Citation (if any) Relevant provisions of the PDPO
1 Conviction:
28 November 2024

Sentence:
19 December 2024
120 hours of Community Service Order Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
WONG Chun-fung
STCC 4201/2024
(Reasons for Sentence not available)
Section 64(3A)
2 Conviction:
26 November 2024

Sentence:
10 December 2024
120 hours of Community Service Order Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
WONG Chau-yin Rachel
ESCC 603/2024
(Reasons for Sentence not available)
Section 64(3A)
(Aiding and abetting to disclose personal data without data subject’s consent)
Conviction:
7 November 2024

Sentence:
2 December 2024
100 hours of Community Service Order HKSAR v
CHAI Chee-ming Jimmy
Section 64(3A)
Conviction:
6 March 2024

Sentence:
20 March 2024
80 hours of Community Service Order HKSAR v
IP Chun-keung Calvin
Section 64(3A)
3 Conviction:
16 October 2024

Sentence:
30 October 2024
80 hours of Community Service Order Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
MAK Tsz-chun
ESCC 2288/2024
(Reasons for Sentence not available)
Section 64(3A)
4 Conviction:
29 August 2024

Sentence:
21 October 2024
4-week imprisonment, suspended for 2 years Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
WONG Yuk-hin
WKCC 2920/2024
(Reasons for Sentence not available)
Section 64(3C)
5 Conviction:
27 September 2024

Sentence:
16 October 2024
120 hours of Community Service Order Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
YEUNG Chi-ho
FLCC 611/2024
(Reasons for Sentence not available)
Section 64(3C)
6 Conviction:
2 September 2024

Sentence:
19 September 2024
30-day imprisonment Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
ZHONG Lau-yin
WKCC 2552/2024
(Reasons for Sentence not available)
Section 64(3C)
7 Conviction:
5 June 2024

Sentence:
26 June 2024
3-month imprisonment, suspended for 2 years Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
HO Harry Hei-yin
WKCC 1620/2024
(Reasons for Sentence not available)
Sections 64(3A), (3C)
8 Conviction:
3 May 2024

Sentence:
24 May 2024
12 months of Probation Order Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
WONG Tak-long
TMCC 199/2024
(Reasons for Sentence not available)
Section 64(3A)
9 Conviction:
3 May 2024

Sentence:
24 May 2024
180 hours of Community Service Order Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
CHU Chung-man
KTCC 465/2024
(Reasons for Sentence not available)
Section 64(3C)
10 Conviction:
22 March 2024

Sentence:
19 April 2024
160 hours of Community Service Order Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
HO Ka-kui
KTCC 567/2024
(Reasons for Sentence not available)
Section 64(3A)
11 Conviction & Sentence:
8 March 2024
2-week imprisonment, suspended for 3 years, and HK$500 fine Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
FU Yau
WKCC 1044/2024
(Reasons for Sentence not available)
Section 64(3A)
12 Conviction & Sentence:
15 February 2024
2-week imprisonment, suspended for 3 years, and HK$500 fine Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
CHAN Tung-ching
WKCC 694/2024
(Reasons for Sentence not available)
Section 64(3A)
13 Conviction:
5 January 2024

Sentence:
31 January 2024
120 hours of Community Service Order Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
Cheung Tse Leung Sonny
TMCC 777/2023
(Reasons for Sentence not available)
Section 64(3A)
14 Conviction:
21 December 2023

Sentence:
16 January 2024
200 hours of Community Service Order Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
Au Yeung Chi-chi and
Lee Wah-bong
ESCC 2899/2023
(Reasons for Sentence not available)
Section 64(3C)
(Conspiracy to disclose personal data without data subject's consent causing specified harm)
15 Conviction & Sentence:
12 January 2024
2-month imprisonment, suspended for 2 years Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
Wong Ho-loon
STCC 142/2024
(Reasons for Sentence not available)
Section 64(3A)
16 Conviction:
30 November 2023

Sentence:
14 December 2023
120 hours of Community Service Order Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
Lam Shuk-yin
STCC 3980/2023
(Reasons for Sentence not available)
Section 64(3C)
17

Conviction:
18 October 2023

Sentence:
3 November 2023

200 hours of Community Service Order Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
HO, Chung-yung Ivan

KCCC 2663/2023
(Reasons for Sentence not available)

Section 64(3C)
18

Conviction
&
Sentence:
31 October 2023

2-month and 2-week imprisonment Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
LEUNG, Fai Johnson

WKCC 4703/2022
(Reasons for Sentence not available)

Sections 64(3A), (3C)
19

Conviction:
13 October 2023

Sentence:
30 October 2023
120 hours of Community Service Order Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
CHUNG Wai-chung

WKCC 3656/2023
(Reasons for Sentence not available)

Section 64(3A)
20

Conviction:
10 August 2023

Sentence:
30 August 2023
80 hours of Community Service Order Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
KEI Chi-chung

WKCC 2252/2023
(Reasons for Sentence not available)

Section 64(3C)
21

Conviction:
24 July 2023

Sentence:
14 August 2023
12 months of Probation Order Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
CHENG Chin-hung

KTCC 653/2023
(Reasons for Sentence not available)

Section 64(3A)
22

Conviction:
12 July 2023

Sentence:
4 August 2023
80 hours of Community Service Order Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
LO Chon-Nam

TMCC 2023/2022
(Reasons for Sentence not available)

Section 64(3A)
23

Conviction:
2 June 2023

Sentence:
16 June 2023
160 hours of Community Service Order Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
SO Tak-mui
STCC 1241/2023
(Reasons for Sentence not available)
Section 64(3A)
24

Conviction:
22 May 2023

Sentence:
7 June 2023
120 hours of Community Service Order Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
LAI Ting-hei
FLCC 16/2023
(Reasons for Sentence not available)
Section 64(3A)
25 Conviction & Sentence:
17 May 2023
4-week imprisonment, suspended for 18 months Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
HUI Kam-fat
STCC 1513/2023
(Reasons for Sentence not available)
Section 64(3C)
26 Conviction:
13 December 2022

Sentence:
28 April 2023
160 hours of Community Service Order Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
IP Chun-hin
WKCC 1638/2022
(Reasons for Sentence not available)
Sections 64(3A), (3C)
27 Conviction & Sentence:
17 March 2023
5-month imprisonment Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
HO Muk-wah
STCC 3168/2022
(Reasons for Sentence not available)
Section 64(3C)
28 Conviction:
1 February 2023

Sentence:
8 March 2023
2-month imprisonment, suspended for 2 years Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
SHAM Chun-kiu
STCC 3175/2022
(Reasons for Sentence not available)
Section 64(3A)
29 Conviction:
6 October 2022

Sentence:
15 December 2022
8-month imprisonment Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
HO Muk-wah
STCC 1989/2022
(Reasons for Sentence not available)
Section 64(3A)
30 Conviction & Sentence:
15 June 2021
1st Defendant – 3rd Defendant: HK$40,000 fine

4th Defendant: Bound-over for 12 months
Magistrates' Court HKSAR v
Next Digital Limited & Others
KTS 566-569/2021
(Reasons for Sentence not available)
Section 64(1)
31 Conviction:
12 January 2021

Sentence:
5 February 2021
240 hours of Community Service Order Magistrates' Court 香港特別行政區 v
[X]
KCCC 2370/2020
(Reasons for Sentence not available)
Section 64(2)1
32 Conviction:
9 October 2020

Sentence:
3 November 2020
18-month imprisonment (4th Charge) District Court 香港特別行政區 v
陳景僖
DCCC 164/2020
[2020] HKDC 890
[2020] HKDC 1020
(Reasons for Verdict
(Chinese version only))

(Reasons for Sentence
(Chinese version only))
Section 64(2)2

1 Section 64(2) has been repealed.

2 Ibid.

(III) Doxxing-related criminal convictions under other offences

No. Date of Decision Court Case Name Case Number / Citation (if any)
1 27 September 2021 District Court 香港特別行政區 v
孔穎琛 (Hung Wing-sum)
DCCC 344/2021
[2021] HKDC 1347
(Reasons for Sentence)
(Chinese version only)

(IV) Contempt of court / breach of injunction

No. Date of Decision Court Case Name Case Number / Citation (if any)
1 14 August 2023 Court of First Instance Secretary for Justice v
CHEUNG Chi Ho (張志豪)
HCMP 598/2022
(Decision)
2 31 July 2023 Court of First Instance Secretary for Justice v
LEE Pak Nap (李柏納)
HCMP 587/2022
(Decision)
3 18 July 2023 Court of First Instance Secretary for Justice v
WONG Kwok Leung
(王國樑)
HCMP 664/2022
(Decision)
4 18 April 2023 Court of First Instance Secretary for Justice v
YEUNG Hin Wun
(楊軒桓)
HCMP 674/2022
(Decision)
5 17 April 2023 Court of First Instance Secretary for Justice v
TSANG Chi Sing
(曾子成)
HCMP 586/2022
(Decision)
6 17 April 2023 Court of First Instance Secretary for Justice v
WONG Chi Fung
(黃之鋒)
HCMP 585/2022
(Decision)
7 12 April 2023 Court of First Instance Secretary for Justice v
YIP Sin Man
(葉倩敏)
HCMP 539/2022
[2023] HKCFI 983
(Decision)
8 17 October 2022 Court of First Instance Secretary for Justice v
Chan Po Hong
(陳寶康)
HCMP 2199/2021
[2022] HKCFI 1468
(Decision)
9 27 April 2022 Court of First Instance Secretary for Justice v
Ho Wai Pan
(何惠彬)
HCMP 1274/2021
[2022] HKCFI 191
(Decision)
10 14 April 2022 Court of First Instance Secretary for Justice v
Lester Shum
(岑敖暉)
HCMP 1158/2021
[2022] HKCFI 1015
(Decision)
11 18 January 2022 Court of First Instance Secretary for Justice v
Sung Ho Tak Edward
(宋浩德)
HCMP 1542/2021
[2022] HKCFI 227
(Decision)
12 29 December 2020 Court of First Instance Secretary for Justice v
Yiu Ka Yu
(姚家瑜)
HCMP 1068/2020
[2021] 1 HKLRD 607
[2020] HKCFI 3148
(Decision)
13 28 December 2020 Court of First Instance Secretary for Justice v
Chan Kin Chung
(陳健聰)
HCMP 744/2020
[2021] 1 HKLRD 563
[2020] HKCFI 3147
(Decision)
14 19 October 2020 Court of First Instance Secretary for Justice v
Cheng Lai King
(鄭麗琼)
HCMP 1256/2020
[2020] 5 HKLRD 356
[2020] HKCFI 2687
(Decision)
15 17 June 2020 Court of First Instance Secretary for Justice v
Chan Oi Yau Riyo
(陳藹柔)
HCMP 249/2020
[2020] 3 HKLRD 494
[2020] HKCFI 1194
(Decision)

C. Direct Marketing

(I) Convictions

Cases involving convictions of direct marketing offences under the Personal Data (Privacy) Ordinance ("PDPO"), which are arranged in reverse chronological order, are listed below:

No. Date of Judgment / Decision Court Case Name Case Number Relevant provisions of the PDPO Media Statement issued by PCPD
1 10 February 2023 Magistrates’
Court
-- ESCC2279/2022 Sections 35C & 35F Media Statement on 10 February 2023
2 7 September 2021 Magistrates’
Court
HKSAR v HGC Global Communications Limited STS5995/2021 Section 35G Not available
3 7 September 2021 Magistrates' Court -- KCS533212/2020 Section 35G Media Statement on 7 September 2021
4 26 August 2021 Magistrates' Court -- FLS8165/2021 & FLS8166/2021 Sections 35C & 35F Not available
5 25 May 2020 Magistrates' Court HKSAR v Hong Kong Broadband Network Limited WKS 1805/2020 – WKS 1810/2020 Sections 35E & 35G Media Statement on 25 May 2020
6 12 September 2019 Magistrates' Court HKSAR v SmarTone Mobile Communications Limited KTS 15644/2019 – KTS 15666/2019 Section 35G Media Statement on 12 September 2019
7 18 June 2019 Magistrates' Court HKSAR v KOA International Limited (KOA) KTS 8132/2019 Section 35C Media Statement on 18 June 2019
8 27 May 2019 Magistrates' Court HKSAR v Artfund International (Hong Kong) Auction Company Limited ESCC 14653/2019 & ESCC 14654/2019 Sections 35C & 35F Media Statement on 27 May 2019
9 21 May 2019 Magistrates' Court HKSAR v Citibank (Hong Kong) Limited KCS 33260/2018 Section 35G Media Statement on 21 May 2019
10 3 April 2019 Magistrates' Court -- TMS 876/2019 & TMS 877/2019 Sections 35C & 35F Media Statement on 3 April 2019
11 22 August 2018 Magistrates' Court HKSAR v Hutchison Telecommunications (Hong Kong) Limited ESS 17013/2018 & ESS 17014/2018 Section 35G Media Statement on 22 August 2018
12 2 January 2018 Magistrates' Court HKSAR v PARKnSHOP (HK) Limited TMS 15921/2017 Section 35E Media Statement on 2 January 2018
13 11 December 2017 Magistrates' Court HKSAR v Physical Health Centre Hong Kong Limited FLS 13690/2017 Section 35G Media Statement on 11 December 2017
14 17 November 2017 Magistrates' Court -- KTS 17034 & 17035/2017 Sections 35C & 35F Media Statement on 17 November 2017
15 10 January 2017 Magistrates' Court HKSAR v DBS Bank (Hong Kong) Limited ESS 41793/2016 Section 35G Media Statement on 10 January 2017
16 6 December 2016 Magistrates' Court HKSAR v Ball Watch (Asia) Company Limited ESS 42685 & 42686/2016 Sections 35C & 35F Media Statement on 6 December 2016
17 Conviction: 4 November 2016
Sentence: 18 November 2016
Magistrates' Court HKSAR v Merchants Wealth Management Advisors Limited and Ping An Property Management Limited TWS 17152, 17155, 17167, 17173, 17176, 17188, 17191/2015; and TWS 17134, 17137, 17140 & 17149/2015 Section 35C Not available
18 16 May 2016 Magistrates' Court HKSAR v GMS (Asia Pacific) Limited KTS 5885 & 5886/2016 Sections 35C & 35G Media Statement on 16 May 2016
19 25 April 2016 Magistrates' Court -- STS 4813 & 4814/2015 Sections 35C & 35F Media Statement on 25 April 2016
20 3 November 2015 Magistrates' Court HKSAR v Hong Kong Professional Health Group Limited TMS 10294/2015 Section 35G Media Statement on 3 November 2015
21 Conviction: 7 September 2015 Sentence: 14 September 2015 Magistrates' Court HKSAR v Links International Relocation Limited operated under the trade name “Links Moving” ESS 26904/2015 Section 35C Media Statement on 14 September 2015

(II) Appeal against the decision of the Magistrates' Court

No. Date of Judgment Court Case Name Case Number / Citation (if any) Relevant provisions of the PDPO Media Statement issued by PCPD
1 2 June 2017 Court of First Instance 香港特別行政區 v 梁竣傑 HCMA 49/2016
(Judgment (Chinese version only))
Section 35J Media Statement on 30 December 2015
(in relation to the Magistrate's conviction (ESS 24178/2015))
2 26 January 2017 Court of First Instance HKSAR v Hong Kong Broadband Network Limited HCMA 624/2015
[2018] 2 HKLRD 1028
[2018] 2 HKLRD 1049
(Judgment)
Section 35G Media Statement on 9 September 2015
(in relation to the Magistrate's conviction (TWS 6311/2015))

D. Exemptions under Part 8 of the PDPO

No. Date of Judgment / Decision Court Case Name Case Number / Citation (if any) Relevant provisions of the PDPO
1 20 April 2018 Court of First Instance Chairman and Deputy Chairman of the Preliminary Investigation Committee of the Medical Council of Hong Kong v Hospital Authority HCMP 2745 & 2747/2016
[2018] 2 HKLRD 842
[2018] HKCFI 843
(Judgment)
Section 58
2 19 November 2013 Court of First Instance Chan Chuen Ping v The Commissioner of Police HCMP 2741/2013
[2014] 1 HKLRD 142
(Judgment)
Section 58
3 30 March 2012 Court of First Instance Oriental Press Group Ltd (東方報業集團有限公司) v Inmediahk.net Ltd HCA 1253/2010
[2012] 2 HKLRD 1004
(Judgment)
Section 58
4 13 May 2010 District Court Able Force Freight Ltd v East Sun Estate Management Ltd (怡生物業管理有限公司) DCMP 295/2010
[2010] 2 HKLRD 1155
(Decision)
Section 58
5 26 January 2006 Court of First Instance Cinepoly Records Co Ltd & Ors v Hong Kong Broadband Network Ltd & Ors HCMP 2487/2005
[2006] 1 HKLRD 255
[2006] 1 HKC 433
(Decision)
Section 58
6 10 December 1998 Court of First Instance Lily Tse Lai Yin v Incorporated Owners of Albert House HCPI 828/1997
[1999] 1 HKC 386
(Reasons for Ruling)
Section 58
7 10 June 1997 District Court M v M FCMC 1425/1988
(Judgment)
Section 58

E. Other provisions under the PDPO

No. Date of Judgment / Decision Court Case Name Case Number / Citation (if any) Relevant AAB Decisions Relevant provisions of the PDPO
1 19 February 2021 Court of First Instance Tsang Po Mann (曾宝雯) v Tsang Ka Kit (曾家傑) and Another DCCJ 4891/2016
[2021] 1 HKLRD 1301
[2021] HKDC 208
(Judgment)
-- Section 66
2 2 April 2020 Court of Appeal Sham Wing Kan (岑永根) v Commissioner of Police CACV 270/2017
[2020] 2 HKLRD 529
[2020] HKCA 186
(Judgment)
-- Section 2
3 4 March 2020 Court of First Instance Chan Shu Chun (陳書春) & Anor v Dr Kung Yan Sum (龔仁心) & Ors HCA 832/2014
[2020] 1 HKLRD 1162
[2020] HKCFI 360
(Decision)
-- Section 18
4 28 April 2017 Court of First Instance Y v The Law Society of Hong Kong HCAL 39/2016
[2017] 2 HKLRD 950
[2017] 3 HKC 436
(Judgment)
-- Section 2(9)
5 1 February 2013 Court of Appeal Re: Hui Kee Chun CACV 4/2012
(Judgment)
AAB 46/2006 Sections 2 & 61
6 31 October 2007 Court of First Instance Wu Kit Ping v Administrative Appeals Board HCAL 60/2007
[2007] 4 HKLRD 849
[2007] 5 HKC 450
(Judgment)
AAB 36/2006
(Chinese version only)
Sections 2, 18 & 20
7 10 June 2004 Court of First Instance 徐冠華 v 個人資料私隱專員 HCAL 94/2003
[2004] 2 HKLRD 840
[2004] HKCFI 1464
(Judgment (Chinese version only))
-- Sections 39
8 11 June 2001 Court of Appeal 曹元緒 v 行政上訴委員會 CACV 960/2000
(Judgment (Chinese version only))
AAB 24/1999 Sections 2

F. Other significant court case(s)

No. Date of Judgment Court Case Name Case Number / Citation (if any)
1 5 June 2023 Court of Final Appeal HKSAR v Choy Yuk Ling (蔡玉玲) FACC 2/2023 and [2023] HKCFA 12
(Judgment)
2 19 October 2022 Court of Appeal  Lai Chee-Ying v Commissioner of Police CACV 356/2022 and CACV 357/2022
[2022] HKCA 1574
(Judgment)
3 30 August 2022 Court of First Instance Lai Chee-Ying v Commissioner of Police HCMP 1218/2020 &
HCAL 738/2022
[2022] HKCFI 2688
(Judgment)
4 21 May 2020 Court of Appeal Junior Police Officers’ Association of the Hong Kong Police Force & Anor v Electoral Affairs Commission & Ors CACV 73/2020
[2020] 3 HKLRD 39
[2020] HKCA 352
[2020] 3 HKC 628
(Judgment)

The copyright in the judgments and court orders is owned by the Government of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region ("Government"). The judgments published on PCPD's website are reproduced from those posted on the Judiciary's website with the permission of the Government. The Government accepts no liability or responsibility for the accuracy or completeness of any of the judgments being published on PCPD's website. The original version of the judgments on the Judiciary website is the only authentic version.

The court judgments on this website are for reference only. Whilst PCPD endeavours to ensure the accuracy of information on this site, no express or implied warranty is given by the PCPD as to the accuracy of information. The PCPD is not liable for any damage or loss whatsoever arising from the use of judgments on the PCPD’s website.